9th Circuit vacates tear gas injunction sought by tenants near Portland ICE facility
Decided- Background: Tenants of an apartment complex across the street from the Portland ICE facility sued federal agencies over exposure to tear gas used to disperse demonstrators, and the District of Oregon issued a preliminary injunction.
- On Nov. 10, a panel of Judges Lee, de Alba and Tung, in an opinion by Judge Tung, vacated the injunction, holding the tenants lack a substantive due process right to be free from non-lethal crowd-control devices used against disruptive demonstrations.
- Judge de Alba dissented and would have held the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their Fifth Amendment substantive due process claim.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · 26-1575 · Nov 10, 2026
9th Circuit vacates injunction limiting crowd-control munitions at Portland ICE facility
Decided- Background: Protesters and independent journalists exposed to tear gas or pepper balls near the Portland ICE facility sued, alleging federal agents targeted them for exercising First Amendment rights, and the District of Oregon enjoined the government.
- On Nov. 10, a panel of Judges Lee, de Alba and Tung, in an opinion by Judge Lee, vacated the preliminary injunction and the provisional class certification.
- The panel held the plaintiffs were not likely to succeed on their retaliation claim and that the injunction, including an order to redesign agent uniforms with identifying markings, was overbroad.
- Judge de Alba concurred in part and dissented in part, and would have kept the ban on firing munitions at the head, neck or torso absent justification for deadly force.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · 26-1609 · Nov 10, 2026
D.C. Circuit affirms injunction barring removal of Voice of America director
Decided- Background: Michael Abramowitz, the head of Voice of America, sued U.S. Agency for Global Media officials, including Kari Lake, after they tried to remove him without approval of a majority of the International Broadcasting Advisory Board, also called the Broadcasting Board.
- Background: The district court granted partial summary judgment on an APA claim and entered a permanent injunction on Aug. 28, 2025, and the officials appealed to the D.C. Circuit, which heard argument on April 23, 2026.
- On Nov. 10, a panel of Chief Judge Srinivasan and Judges Pillard and Pan, in an opinion by Judge Pillard, affirmed the injunction barring removal of Abramowitz without approval of a majority of that Board.
- The court held the district court had jurisdiction and that 22 U.S.C. section 6205(e) is consistent with Article II, so the agency's unilateral attempt to fire Abramowitz was contrary to law.
- The court noted that six of the seven Broadcasting Board seats remain empty.
Judges: Author: Pillard · Panel: Srinivasan, Pan
U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit · 25-5314 · Nov 10, 2026
10th Circuit partly affirms denial of immunity in Emporia State tenure firings
Decided- Background: Nine tenured professors sued Emporia State University and Kansas Board of Regents officials under 42 U.S.C. section 1983 after they were fired under a suspension of tenure protections.
- Background: The officials appealed a District of Kansas order that denied most of their qualified-immunity defense, bringing the case to the Tenth Circuit on an interlocutory appeal.
- On Nov. 9, a panel of Judges Matheson, Ebel, and Eid, in an opinion by Judge Ebel, affirmed the denial of immunity on procedural due process and related conspiracy claims, finding a state-created property interest in tenure and a clearly established procedural due process violation at the motion-to-dismiss stage.
- The court reversed the denial of immunity on substantive due process claims against all defendants, and reversed as to non-property claims against the Board of Regents defendants and defendants Thomas, Lovett, and Johnson, remanding with instructions to dismiss those claims.
- Judge Eid concurred in part and dissented in part, saying qualified immunity should also have barred the procedural due process claims because the law was not clearly established.
Judges: Author: Ebel · Panel: Matheson, Eid · Concurrence: Eid · Dissent: Eid
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · 25-3032 · Nov 9, 2026
10th Circuit revives EEOC disability suit against Appliance Factory
Decided- Background: The EEOC sued A & A Appliance, Inc., doing business as Appliance Factory, alleging it violated the ADA by failing to accommodate sales associate Karima Javanzad's leave request and firing her on June 10, 2020.
- Background: The District of Colorado granted summary judgment for the company, and the EEOC appealed to the Tenth Circuit.
- On Nov. 6, a panel of Judges Matheson, McHugh, and Federico, in an opinion by Judge McHugh, reversed that judgment and remanded, holding a reasonable jury could find the employer was on notice of a disability and that Javanzad requested a reasonable accommodation.
- Judge Matheson concurred in part and dissented in part, agreeing on notice of a disability but concluding a reasonable jury could not find she provided a plausibly reasonable expected duration of impairment.
Judges: Author: McHugh · Panel: Matheson, Federico · Concurrence: Matheson · Dissent: Matheson
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · 25-1451 · Nov 6, 2026
10th Circuit vacates injunction that would have allowed a fifth NCAA season
Decided- Background: Division I student-athletes who had already used four seasons sued the NCAA under section 1 of the Sherman Act after it adopted a five-season eligibility rule in June 2026 but declined to apply that rule retroactively.
- Background: The District of Colorado entered a preliminary injunction ordering the NCAA to let the plaintiffs compete for a fifth season, and the NCAA appealed to the Tenth Circuit.
- On Nov. 6, a panel of Judges McHugh, Kelly, and Moritz, in an opinion by Judge McHugh, reversed that order and vacated the injunction.
- The court held the district court clearly erred in defining the relevant labor market as all NCAA Division I athletics in the United States, so the plaintiffs did not show a likelihood of success on the merits.
Judges: Author: McHugh · Panel: Kelly, Moritz
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · 26-1309 · Nov 6, 2026